After considering the validity of quantitative research last November, this month I
did some research using a quantitative research method to investigate the
differences between those that participate in physical communities and those that
participate in online communities. I was particularly interested in the beliefs that
people in these communities hold and the impact they have on how they act.
To find out whether lurkers, who are people who do not contribute to online
communities, are similar to people who have the condition social phobia I decided
to use the Social Thoughts and Beliefs Scale. I chose this scale because it asks
people to state whether they find a particular belief characteristic of themselves,
which is all you can really accurately get from a quantitative questionnaire.
Based on the results I got from the study in which I surveyed two online
communities (Hyperlex and MCompuSIG and two physical communities (Efail Isaf and Trefforest) I found the
following:
A total of 4 respondents from the organic communities (total=18) and 9 from the
online communities (total=19) were classed as lurkers. This suggests that in 2006 in
village communities as many as 78% of actors are likely to have a discussion with
someone in their community or contribute to it in a way others will notice whereas
only 53% of those that take part in online communities will do the same. Analysing
the results of the questionnaire revealed that lurkers in online communities had a
Mean score of 27.78 on the Social Thoughts and Beliefs Scale, whereas the
controls had a Mean score of 24.50 The results also revealed that lurkers in organic
communities had a Mean score of 25.75, whereas the controls had a Mean score
of 16.00. In a study of the scale those with social phobia scored a Mean of 52.4 and
the control group scored a Mean of 22.3. Whilst the lurkers in both online and
physical communities had higher scores than the controls, their scores were nearer
that of individuals without social phobia than those with the condition. However
these figures reveal that those who use online communities are more likely to find
the beliefs on the Social Thoughts and Beliefs Scales to be characteristic of them
than those in organic communities.