Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s suggestion that the UK could consider rejoining the EU risks turning a necessary debate about improving relations with Europe into a false choice, namely either accept the present Brexit settlement or return to full membership.
Britain has a stronger third option. It can remain outside the EU, use its CPTPP membership to build a serious Pacific partnership, strengthen its Commonwealth relationships, and negotiate a far closer, Canada-style settlement with Europe.
Burnham has raised rejoining as an option rather than announced it as government policy, so this is precisely the moment to put that alternative on the table.
The point is not to turn Britain away from Europe. It is to secure the closest workable European partnership without surrendering the ability to shape relationships elsewhere. The UK–EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement already provides a foundation for tariff-free trade in goods that meet its rules of origin. A “Canada++” negotiation would build on that foundation, seeking stronger arrangements for services, standards, research, security and mobility where both sides see a benefit.
CPTPP gives Britain a place in a major trading partnership beyond Europe; UK businesses gained full access to its membership benefits on 1 September 2026. Britain should use that position actively, rather than treat accession as a completed diplomatic trophy. It should cultivate investment, digital commerce, professional services and supply-chain links with fellow members.
An enhanced Commonwealth relationship would add another dimension. It need not pretend that Commonwealth membership is itself a free-trade agreement. Its value lies in turning longstanding relationships into specific agreements on trade, education, qualifications, research and investment. Canada offers a useful illustration of the underlying strategy: it participates in CPTPP while maintaining substantial trade and political agreements with the EU. Britain can likewise maintain overlapping partnerships rather than be defined by one of them.
“Canada++ associate membership” should be presented as a proposal for a bespoke UK–EU relationship, not as an existing legal status that Britain can claim automatically. Canada’s EU trade and strategic agreements demonstrate the scope for cooperation outside membership; discussion in 2026 of a possible new EU association with Canada gives the idea added political relevance. The UK would still have to negotiate its own terms with the EU.
That negotiation should place the Good Friday Agreement and the practical needs of Northern Ireland at its centre. A durable settlement would seek to ease trade across these islands while protecting the rights, cooperation and consent on which peace depends. Britain’s European relationship should be designed around those obligations, not reduced to a contest between the slogans “Brexit” and “rejoin.”
The argument to Burnham is therefore straightforward: do not make EU membership the destination before testing a better settlement outside it. Britain can be a committed European partner, an active CPTPP member and a more purposeful Commonwealth partner at the same time. Canada++ is the means to make those relationships complementary rather than competing.