JESSE FOOT, in In My View (Cornish Guardian, March 2) advocates Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs theory as a way of understanding human growth, even though, as he points out, Maslow’s theories were constructed on his evaluation of elites. This is equally as ineffective as Sigmund Freud basing all his theories on his mentally-impaired patients.
I also made the same mistake as Jesse, by accepting the legitimacy of Maslow’s framework in my undergraduate dissertation, as it was recommended as a model for online community design by Amy Jo Kim.
Five years later, in 2007, I had a paper published in the Computers In Human Behavior journal where I dismissed Maslow’s hierarchy of needs in favour of my proposed ‘ecological cognition framework’.
Maslow’s idea that there is a hierarchy of needs is completely flawed. He says that people cannot meet their ‘esteem needs’, such as to be social, if their ‘deficit needs’, such as excretion, food and sleep, are not met.
One just has to look at problematic internet use in China where people sit in front of a computer nearly all day playing games like World Of Warcraft – they won’t sleep any more than necessary or even move in order to relieve themselves.
Even during the Second World War, those in concentration camps whose so-called deficit needs weren’t met were still sociable and empathetic.
So as ‘orderly’ as Maslow’s framework may have seemed in 2002 to both academics like Ben Shneiderman and myself, in 2011 we have moved on, and my framework is now used in theses from degrees to PhD, with Maslow just a footnote in history.
Great post thanks!